Topic on Talk:Loathsome Characters Wiki

Jump to navigation Jump to search

Should the Donald Duck page be restored?

Summary by Hookuai

By the way, there is a rule that won't allow you to put any,characters that is supposed to be mean because they carry the story along

Mickey Mouse (talkcontribs)

After looking back, I realized Donald is in fact heavily flanderized in some modern Mickey Mouse media such as The Adorable Couple and Down the Hatch (with MMCH, Mickey and The Roadster Racers and DuckTales 2017 (kinda) being the exceptions), this page should mainly focus on the incarnations that happened after Clarence Nash (Donald's original voice actor) died, I also realized Donald is more grumpy than usual in Mickey's Once Upon a Christmas. However, the page should be titled Donald Duck (2013) because that's the major flanderized version.

However, the original page got deleted because they thinked it would not belong here due to Donald's popularity, so I wanted to know if Donald should get his page restored because he in fact can be unlikable in newer media, but I will in fact make a classic/educational Donald page in Great Characters wiki

Matthew The Guy (talkcontribs)

No. Sorry.

Mickey Mouse (talkcontribs)

Do you have any reasons why?

Matthew The Guy (talkcontribs)

A character can't be on this wiki just because of some "mean" and "grumpy" traits, which is one of the newer rules and honestly a rule that should have been here in the first place.